Today's Topic for Faith 'n Fiction Saturdays:
(Yes, I know this is Monday...)
Christian fiction is generally known for being clean and non-offensive, but lately there's been a lot of chatter about edgy Christian fiction and the need for Christian fiction to be more realistic. Christian fiction has certainly changed and contains a lot more edge than it used to. This makes some readers uncomfortable and I was wondering what you line is? What would push the envelope too far for a Christian fiction novel for you? Language? Sex? Violence? Main characters who never believe in Jesus? If you came across something that offended you in a Christian fiction book, how would you handle it?
I really like edgy Christian fiction. I like when a storyline feels real and deals with issues that real people could face. And real people face hard/tempting situations in this world; they're not sheltered just because they're Christians. The difference is in how they handle it. I love suspense and I love romance, and for a suspense novel to be good it has got to be edgy.
All that said, I do NOT care for foul language and sex scenes. That is what I avoid in general market books and a lot of why I like Christian fiction - I don't have to weed through that stuff. I have read some Christian fiction that had mild language and if it's sporadic that's ok, but I've read one book that had it heavily throughout the book and that was a little too much for me. But I don't like unrealistic comments from characters...something no one would really say in replacement of a curse word.
I also feel that the intimate scenes are plenty edgy in Christian fiction and do not need to get any more explicit. I like it when they are descriptive but tasteful; I don't like it when they are boring and prude. I don't mind some violence but not really graphic, gory violence.
As far as if the main character doesn't believe in Jesus, I don't really keep a "tally sheet" for that. I guess it just depends on the story and how it's done. It's not a deal breaker for me as long as the seed is there by the end of the book and it looks like it will grow. But then again I like general market books that are not "Christian" but are good, clean stories.
If I did come across something offensive in Christian fiction, I might dismiss it and just keep reading if it's minor. Or I would abandon the book all together if it's highly offensive. I also would have no problem posting it in my review on the blog as well. That is something I would want to know as a reader and would appreciate reading in a review.
Going the other extreme, I definitely do not like cheesy or preachy Christian fiction. It's as much of a turn-off as offensive language, strange as that sounds. And I have abandoned books for that reason, too. If I'm reading and all I can think is "gimme a break!" then I'm too distracted from the story to even enjoy it.
So this is a little late for the Saturday posting, but I'd love to hear what you have to say on this topic!
Haha, I've so been there - "Gimme a break!" Especially when it comes to cheesy romances. I'm married and definitely appreciate when the hardships of REAL LIFE are acknowledged.
ReplyDeleteI feel the same as you. I love edgy and real-to-life. That said, I like to keep it as clean as possible... if I wouldn't watch it on TV I'd rather not read it in a book, lol. I've put books down for both reasons, too - too cheesy/preachy and pushing the limits of edgy.
I enjoy the edgier stuff too. I've always enjoyed Christian fiction, but I have a hard time relating to most of the characters because they seem too perfect. I think it's much more helpful to read about people who truly do struggle with things, rather than people who are practically perfect.
ReplyDeleteI am all for edgy Christian romances. To me it is more realistic and am glad the Christian market seems to be evolving beyond the preachy and cheesy.
ReplyDelete